Arsenal led at half-time at St James' Park on Saturday evening and came home with a 2-2 draw in the Premier League. Newcastle turned it round after the break, Noni Madueke rescued a point and David Raya went off injured. The leaders are six points clear, and the fan YouTubers on both sides watched the same match and saw two different results.
AFTV and Troopz: two points dropped
For 45 minutes it was one-way traffic. Kai Havertz robbed Lewis Hall and slid in Eberechi Eze, who finished first time on 33 minutes, his first Premier League goal since April. Mikel Arteta's verdict afterwards was blunt: "My feeling is that we lost two points today."
The Arsenal rooms were on the same page as their manager. AFTV asked the obvious question: two points dropped or one point rescued? The panel went for the first option. "For me, I think it's three points dropped today or two points dropped, I would say," said one voice, before settling on the lower figure. On the first half: "I don't remember Newcastle getting a shot on target at all." The reply: "They didn't."
Troopz didn't need a debate. His video title did the work: "2 POINTS DROPPED KMT!!"
Martin Ødegaard and the 49th minute
Matthias Jaissle changed three players at half-time, bringing on Tino Livramento, Jacob Ramsey and Anthony Elanga. Four minutes after the restart, Martin Ødegaard miscontrolled a throw-in, the ball ran to William Osula and he set up Harvey Barnes to equalise. On 62 minutes Dan Burn headed down a Hall corner and Malick Thiaw poked Newcastle in front.
The Arsenal titles that followed read like a disciplinary hearing. Miss Melina went with "2ND HALF CAPITULATION, WE ONLY HAVE OURSELVES TO BLAME". CalumTalksAFC called it an "INEXCUSABLE 2ND HALF!" and NorthsideLDN upgraded that to "SACKABLE".
Ødegaard did his own repair work. On 78 minutes he found Madueke on the counter, and the winger dummied two defenders before a slightly deflected shot beat Lukas Hornicek. According to BBC Sport, it was Arsenal's first shot of the second half. Not everyone is furious. The Global Gooners Podcast titled its reaction "WHY I'M NOT ANGRY AT THE DRAW!", and even the AFTV panel conceded: "We're actually 2-1 down at a venue that posed a lot of challenges for us over the years."
David Raya: shoulder injury
Shortly after Thiaw's goal, Raya was hurt in a collision with Osula after claiming a corner and was helped off with a shoulder injury. Kepa Arrizabalaga replaced him. Arteta said Raya would probably have an MRI scan on Sunday: "At the moment I don't know." Lee Gunner held an emergency meeting on the injury overnight, and Arsenal fans are waiting on the scan.
Bruno Guimarães: booed, then applauded
It was Bruno Guimarães' first game back at St James' Park since leaving for north London, and Arsenal's own match report says his every touch was booed, kick-off included. Sky Sports called it a quiet performance. He was withdrawn in the second half, and Newcastle Fans TV posted the clip of his substitution.
The Newcastle rooms were not sentimental. The Magpie Channel TV titled its reaction "Jaissle FIGHTBACK As Bruno BOTTLES It!" and LOADED MAG NUFC went with "Bruno HUMBLED". At full time, Sky reports, the first Newcastle captain to lift a trophy in 56 years did a lap of the pitch and was cheered. Our preview found the Newcastle channels split on booing him. The ground solved it by doing both, in that order.
Matthias Jaissle: the half-time gamble
The Guardian reports the home crowd was close to turning on Jaissle at half-time. By full time he was talking about goosebumps. "A big, big point," he said. "When you feel the momentum in the second half, then you're almost feeling it's two points lost."
So both dugouts flirted with two points lost, which is mathematically awkward. Geordie Dread TV took issue with Arteta's version in its title. Newcastle Fans TV went with "Newcastle stop Arsenal from winning again!"
Two points or one
Arsenal's four-game Premier League run of wins without conceding is over, but they are still six points clear of Brighton and Manchester City, with Brighton at Hull on Sunday. Newcastle are 12th. Opta notes that since the start of last season, all five of Newcastle's Premier League home draws have finished 2-2. At St James' Park, it's practically the house special.
